Call Us: (310) 798-9154
Apply NowRequest A QuoteFree Rental Analysis

Should You Self-Manage Your South Bay Rental Property or Hire a Property Manager?

Owner reviewing paperwork outside a South Bay rental property

Plenty of South Bay owners manage their own rentals, and some do it well. If you own a house in Torrance or a fourplex in Redondo Beach, live ten minutes away and enjoy the work, self-managing can make sense.

But the job has changed. California rent restrictions, notice requirements, inspection deadlines and security deposit regulations have all tightened in the last few years, and a mistake that used to cost an afternoon can now result in a costly lawsuit. Here is an honest way to decide which side of the line you are on.

What Self-Managing Actually Involves 

Most owners underestimate the job because they picture the visible parts: collecting rent and fixing a leak. The full list is much more extensive.

  • Marketing vacancies, showing units and screening applicants consistently and in line with Fair Housing laws
  • Drafting new and renewal leases, including the disclosures California requires
  • Calculating rent increases and properly notifying residents under the local rules and regulations that apply to your property
  • Processing move-outs, which includes accounting for security deposits appropriately, processing security deposit refunds by the deadline and providing residents the necessary back-up, including itemized receipts, photos at move-in, photos at move-out and photos after repairs
  • Taking after-hours maintenance calls and sourcing licensed, reliable vendors
  • Keeping up with inspection requirements, such as balcony inspections on qualifying buildings
  • Properly serving non-payment notices, and knowing when to contact an attorney
  • Performing preventative maintenance and regular unit inspections to make sure you do not have any habitability complaints or safety issues that can result in a costly lawsuit
  • Keeping up with legislation and implementing the various new laws that come up each year

Individually, these tasks are manageable, but juggling them simultaneously, each with its own requirements and deadlines, creates challenges.

Signs Self-Managing Is Working 

  • You live close to the property and can get there quickly
  • Your tenants are long term and turnover is rare
  • You have a short list of reliable vendors you trust
  • You know which rent rules apply to your property and have kept up with recent changes
  • You keep up with the annual disclosure requirements and always update your lease
  • Your rents are near market and your books are clean

Signs It Is Time to Hire Help 

Your rents have fallen well below the market

Long tenancies in self-managed rentals often drift far below market, because raising rent on people you know is uncomfortable. Under AB 1482 there is a ceiling on annual increases, which means an increase you skip this year is not always one you can make up later. A gap that compounds quietly for a decade can be the single biggest cost of self-managing.

You are not sure which rules apply 

Rent increase rules differ by city across the South Bay. Torrance, Redondo Beach and Hawthorne follow the state cap for covered units. Inglewood has its own ordinance that works differently by building size. Some addresses that read Los Angeles or Torrance actually sit in the City of LA or in unincorporated Los Angeles County, each with different rules. If you have to look this up every time, the risk of getting it wrong is real.

Vacancies are taking longer to fill 

Every week a unit sits empty is rent you do not get back. If your vacancies are running longer than a few weeks, the usual causes are pricing, presentation or slow response to inquiries, and all three are fixable. 

You own more than one property, or you live far away

The work grows with every door and every mile. Owners who live out of the area, or who own rentals in more than one city, often find the coordination costs more than the management fee.

Operations are taking over your week

If your phone dictates your schedule, the question is no longer whether you can do it. It is whether that is the best use of your time. 

You plan to move back in or sell someday

For many single-family owners, the house is a future home or the next sale. Protecting its condition, documenting it at every move-in and move-out, and keeping the right lease terms in place can matter more than the last dollar of rent.

How to Think About the Cost 

Most property management fees are a percentage of the rent actually collected, plus fees for leasing a vacant unit. Ask any manager you interview exactly what the fee covers and what costs extra. 

Then compare that fee against what self-managing really costs you. Count the rent you are leaving on the table, the days units sit vacant, the vendor markups you pay because you do not have volume pricing, and the hours you spend. Owners who run the numbers honestly are often surprised by where they land. 

What to Look for if You Hire a Manager 

  • A California Department of Real Estate license. A company that collects rent for others needs one, and you can look it up at dre.ca.gov.
  • Experience with properties like yours. Ask how many single-family homes and how many multi-unit buildings they manage, since each comes with different work.
  • Local knowledge of the laws your property is subject to
  • Understanding their systems for keeping up with market rents, preventive maintenance and asset management
  • In-house maintenance coordination and a clear answer about after-hours calls
  • Clear monthly statements and an owner portal
  • Five-star reviews from both owners and residents

Frequently Asked Questions 

Is a property manager worth it for one house or a small building?

It depends on how close you live, how much time you have and how current your rents are. For many owners of a single-family rental or a small multi-unit building, the rent gained from market-based pricing and shorter vacancies usually more than covers the cost of the management fee.

Can I hire a property manager for just one house or one building?

Yes. Many managers, including Jamico Properties, take single buildings, small multi-unit properties, condos and single-family homes.

Do property managers in California need a license?

A company that collects rent and leases property on behalf of owners generally needs a real estate broker license from the California Department of Real Estate.

Can I go back to self-managing later?

Usually, subject to the notice terms in your management agreement. Read the termination clause before you sign.

Not Sure Which Side You Are On? 

Jamico Properties has managed South Bay rental homes and apartment buildings since 1995 and manages more than 2,400 units across California and Oklahoma. We can show you what your home or units should rent for today and what we could do to maximize your return, so you can make a decision with real numbers in front of you.

Request a free rental analysis to get started. 

This article is for general information and is not legal or financial advice. Consult an attorney about your specific property and agreements. 

About the Author

Owner and CEO of Jamico Properties

Christie Slatcher is the owner and CEO of Jamico Properties, a family-owned property management company that has looked after rental property in the South Bay and in Tulsa since 1995. Her team manages more than 2,400 units across both markets, from single rentals to multi-unit buildings. She writes from what actually comes up in the day to day, not from theory.

Jamico Properties, a DBA of Jamison Management Company. DRE #01356743.